Will a Polygraph Examiner Tell You if You Failed?
The question of whether a polygraph examiner will tell you if you failed is complex and doesn't have a simple yes or no answer. The truth is more nuanced, dependent on several factors including the examiner's policies, the context of the examination, and legal considerations.
While some examiners might offer a preliminary assessment of the results, many will avoid explicitly stating "you passed" or "you failed." This is because polygraph results are often considered inconclusive and lack widespread scientific acceptance in court. Instead of a direct pass/fail declaration, you might receive a vague summary of the test's outcome or be asked to schedule another session.
Let's delve deeper into some key aspects:
What Happens After a Polygraph Test?
After undergoing a polygraph examination, the examiner will usually analyze the collected physiological data. This analysis is subjective and depends on the examiner's interpretation of the charts. They're looking for inconsistencies between your physiological responses and your verbal statements.
Why Examiners Avoid Explicit Pass/Fail Statements
There are several reasons why examiners might avoid a direct pass/fail statement:
-
Lack of Scientific Consensus: The scientific validity of polygraph tests is highly debated. Many researchers and legal professionals question their accuracy and reliability. A definitive pass/fail statement could be misleading and potentially lead to incorrect conclusions.
-
Legal Ramifications: In many jurisdictions, polygraph results are inadmissible in court as evidence. An examiner might avoid a clear statement to limit potential legal issues.
-
Ethical Considerations: Some examiners believe that giving a definite pass/fail assessment without clear scientific backing is unethical.
What You Can Expect Instead of a Direct "Pass/Fail"
Instead of a straightforward result, you might encounter these scenarios:
-
A vague summary of the findings: The examiner might provide a general description of the test results, such as indicating areas of concern or consistency. This approach avoids a concrete pass/fail judgment.
-
A recommendation for further testing: If the results are inconclusive or ambiguous, the examiner might suggest another polygraph test to clarify the findings.
-
No immediate feedback: In some cases, you may not receive any immediate feedback on your test performance. The examiner might need more time to analyze the data or might require a follow-up meeting to discuss the results.
How Accurate Are Polygraph Tests?
The accuracy of polygraph tests is highly debated. Studies on the accuracy of polygraph testing have yielded varied results, and the overall consensus is that the reliability of this method is questionable. The results are often interpreted subjectively, and the possibility of false positives or negatives is significant.
Can You Be Forced to Take a Polygraph Test?
In most cases, you cannot be compelled to take a polygraph test. However, depending on the circumstances and your employment or legal status, there might be some exceptions to this rule. However, the results of a polygraph test are not typically admissible in court, except under very specific circumstances.
In conclusion, while you might receive some indication of the examiner's interpretation of the polygraph results, a clear-cut "pass" or "fail" declaration is unusual. The lack of scientific consensus, legal considerations, and ethical concerns often lead examiners to provide a more nuanced and cautious evaluation. Always consult with legal counsel if a polygraph test is part of a legal proceeding.
