Workers' compensation cases rarely go to trial. While the exact percentage varies by state and the specifics of the claim, it's generally accepted that a vast minority of cases ever reach a courtroom. This is due to several factors, including the nature of the system itself and the incentives for all parties involved to settle outside of court.
Why Are Workers' Comp Trials So Uncommon?
Several factors contribute to the low trial rate in workers' compensation cases:
-
The System's Design: Workers' compensation systems are designed to provide swift and efficient resolution of workplace injury claims. The emphasis is on prompt medical care and benefit payments, not lengthy litigation. States often have specific processes and timelines designed to encourage settlements.
-
Settlement Incentives: Both employers and insurance carriers often prefer settlement to avoid the uncertainty and potential high costs associated with a trial. The potential for a larger award at trial is balanced against the expenses of legal representation, expert witnesses, and the risk of an unfavorable judgment. Employees, too, often prefer a quicker resolution, even if it means accepting a slightly less favorable settlement than what a jury might award.
-
Mediation and Arbitration: Many states actively encourage alternative dispute resolution methods like mediation and arbitration before a case can proceed to trial. These processes offer a more informal and less expensive way to resolve disputes outside of court. Many cases are successfully settled during these processes.
-
Evidence Requirements: Proving a case in workers' compensation often requires specific types of evidence, such as medical reports and witness testimony. Gathering this evidence can be time-consuming and expensive. The strength of the evidence often influences the decision to settle or proceed to trial.
What Factors Increase the Likelihood of a Trial?
While uncommon, some situations make a trial more likely:
-
Disputes over Causation: When there's significant disagreement about whether the injury is work-related, the case is more likely to go to trial.
-
Serious and Permanent Injuries: Cases involving catastrophic injuries resulting in significant long-term medical expenses and lost wages are more likely to end up in court. The higher stakes often justify the increased costs and risks of litigation.
-
Denial of Benefits: If the employer or insurer denies benefits outright, the employee may have no choice but to pursue legal action to receive compensation.
-
Complex Medical Issues: Cases involving complicated medical conditions or conflicting medical opinions may require a judge or jury to weigh the evidence and make a determination, making trial more probable.
-
Bad Faith Claims: If an employee believes the employer or insurer acted in bad faith during the claims process (e.g., failing to investigate properly or delaying benefits), they may be more likely to pursue a trial to seek additional compensation for the emotional distress and other damages.
How Can I Avoid Going to Trial in a Workers' Comp Case?
The best way to avoid a workers' comp trial is to:
-
Document Everything: Thoroughly document the injury, medical treatment, and lost wages. Keep accurate records of all communications with the employer and insurance company.
-
Seek Prompt Medical Attention: Obtain timely medical care from a qualified physician and follow their recommendations diligently.
-
Cooperate Fully: Cooperate with the employer and insurance company's investigation, providing all necessary information promptly.
-
Consider Mediation or Arbitration: Be open to alternative dispute resolution methods to resolve your claim outside of court.
-
Hire an Experienced Attorney: If your claim is complex or disputed, consulting with a qualified workers' compensation attorney is crucial. They can guide you through the process and help you negotiate a fair settlement.
What is the average cost of a workers' comp trial?
The cost of a workers' compensation trial can vary greatly depending on several factors, including the complexity of the case, the length of the trial, and the location. However, it's safe to say that the costs are significantly higher than settling out of court. These costs include attorney fees, expert witness fees, court costs, and potentially lost wages during the litigation process. These combined costs can easily amount to tens of thousands, if not hundreds of thousands, of dollars.
While the precise percentage of workers' compensation cases that go to trial is difficult to pinpoint definitively without state-specific data, it's safe to say that the overwhelming majority settle before trial. Understanding the factors that influence this decision and proactive steps to facilitate a settlement are crucial for both employees and employers involved in these claims.
